| Platinum | Mara's Brazilian Cuisine |
| Gold | Cozumel Mexican Grill |
| Silver | Los Jaripeos |
| Bronze | Takiza |
| Top Pick | El Azteca Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | El Jaripeo Menasha |
| Top Pick | Los Tres Amigos |
| Top Pick | Rodney's Cafe |
| Top Pick | Solea Mexican Grill |
| Top Pick | South of The Border |