| Platinum | Parnell Place |
| Gold | Wendt's On the Lake |
| Silver | TJ's Highland |
| Bronze | Debs Spare Time |
| Top Pick | Andy's Pub & Grub |
| Top Pick | Beckets Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Fisher's Westward Ho |
| Top Pick | Gardina's Kitchen & Bar |
| Top Pick | South Side Ice Yacht Club |
| Top Pick | Two Brothers Family Restaurant |