| Platinum | Two Brothers Family Restaurant |
| Gold | Becket's Restaurant |
| Gold | Pete's Garage |
| Gold | Roxy Supper Club |
| Gold | TJ's Harbor Restaurant |
| Gold | West End Pizza |
| Silver | Jeff's on Rugby |
| Bronze | Ruby Owl |
| Top Pick | Chalice |
| Top Pick | The Hangar Bar and Grill |
| Caramel Crisp Corner | |
| Rocky Rococo Pizza & Pasta |