| Platinum | West End Pizza |
| Gold | Eaton's Fresh Pizza |
| Gold | Ratch & Deb's Pizza |
| Gold | Rocky Rococo Pizza & Pasta |
| Silver | Pizza King On Ohio |
| Bronze | Dr. Benzie's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Mineshaft Oshkosh |
| Top Pick | Parm |
| Top Pick | Pizza King On Murdock |
| Top Pick | Red's Pizza & Catering |