| Platinum | J & R Auto Service |
| Gold | Turn Key Auto |
| Silver | Simon's Auto Service |
| Bronze | The Wrenchin' Badger, LLC |
| Top Pick | Auto Authority |
| Top Pick | Car-X Tire & Auto |
| Top Pick | Jacobson Auto Sales |
| Top Pick | Kenny's Auto Repair & Service |
| Top Pick | Quent's Service Center |
| Top Pick | West Side Tire & Auto |