| Platinum | Oshkosh Spark Permanent Jewelry |
| Gold | Indigo Sage |
| Silver | The Turquoise Door |
| Bronze | Reimer Jewelers |
| Top Pick | Alyssa & Anna Fine Jewelry |
| Top Pick | Frugal Fashion, LLC |
| Top Pick | Link'D With a Spark |
| Top Pick | Oshkosh Jewelers |
| Top Pick | Sealed With a Spark LLC |
| Top Pick | Tennies Jewelry |