| Platinum | 01 Vintage |
| Gold | Second Chance Thrift Store |
| Silver | Bowenstreet Repeats |
| Bronze | St Vincent De Paul |
| Top Pick | Fabulous Finds |
| Top Pick | Frugal Fashion, LLC |
| Top Pick | Mojo's |
| Top Pick | Omro Thrift Store |
| Top Pick | The Turquoise Door |
| Top Pick | Winneconne Thrift & Gift |